|
Know Your
Client's Debt-to-credit Ratio - and How it Can Hurt
By Thomas R. McKee, president, New West Credit Consultants
REPRINTED FROM SCOTSMAN GUIDE RESIDENTIAL EDITION, MARCH 2005
Loan officers are accustomed to working with debt-to-income ratio and are
well-aware of its implications and effects on their clients' loan
statuses. But can a debt-to-income ratio help you fund more loans or
obtain more favorable rates and terms for you customers?
The answer, in a word: absolutely.
How can I calculate the debt-to-credit ratio?
To calculate the ratio, simply divide the current balances on people's
revolving lines by the credit card limits. Credit-card balances can vary
widely, which can affect credit scores dramatically. The ratio only
pertains to revolving debt, usually credit cards - though recent industry
speculation is that it is factored into home-equity lines of credit.
How does it affect my client's scores?
As a general rule, clients are in good shape if they use less than 30
percent of their available credit. A 30 percent to 50 percent
debt-to-credit ratio usually will see a drop of 10 to 20 plus points. From
50 to 70 percent, we have seen an average drop of approximately 30 to 50
points. Any ratio higher than 70 percent significantly diminishes scores
to the tune of about 70 to 100 points.
Average U.S. consumers use 24 percent of their available credit, which
does not affect their credit negatively. According to a recent Experian
Consumer Direct study, 16 percent of consumers are using more than 50
percent, which definitely can have a negative affect on their scores.
We have even seen clients with otherwise "clean" credit and no negative
information on their files watch their credit ratings plummet down from an
"A" to a "D" or even an "F" file rating because they "maxed out" their
credit cards. Worse, some might be over their credit limits. According to
the study, those with higher debt-to-credit ratios carry an average of 4.6
credit cards, with the national average being 3.2 cards.
How can I help my clients with high ratios?
This may be the hard part.
- Option 1: The most obvious answer is simply to help them pay
down the balances. Unfortunately a person carrying 4.6 cards, each with
an average credit limit of $5,000, and a debt-to-credit ratio of 90
percent needs to pay $13,800 just to get the ratio down to 30 percent.
Most people simply Don't have the cash or immediate assets for this,
especially if you want to close the loan in a month.
- Option 2: Open new credit-card accounts, which would lower
the debt-to-credit ratio. Here again, as a credit score temporarily
falls upon opening new accounts, it may be a viable long-term solution
until your client can pay down the debt. In the short term, though, your
client's score is moving backward, which won't help you find the loan.
- Option 3: Call credit-card companies and see if they will
increase your client's credit limit. Most companies will have to pull a
new credit report, but if you can secure a higher limit, it will lower
the ratio and boost your client's score According to Experian, Equifax
and TransUnion, the three major credit-reporting agencies, the ratio is
30 percent of your FICO score, with only payment history serving as a
stronger factor. Don't forget the importance of your debt-to-credit
ratio, also referred to as credit utilization, for your clients.
Thomas R. McKee is president of New West Credit Consultants, a firm
that works with mortgage professionals to help improve their client's
credit scores to obtain more favorable rates and tems on their home
loans. He can be reached at (605)323-1316; email him at tom@newwestcc.com.
Visit New West Credit's Web site at www.newwestcc.com
Request your FREE
Analysis Appointment online right now
through the secure server for an answer within 24 business hours!
|